« The Big Scary Idea : Meh... | Main | Gerstmann and the state of videogame criticism »

November 29, 2007

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451626369e200e54f9141e28833

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference New Collection of Critical Essays about Modern Fantasy announced...:

Comments

Steve

Ooh ... classy - not a mention of Harry Potter in the TOC ;-)

Jacob Martin

I get the feeling that we need a book like this. I know I need it, looks like a solid read. As a modern fantasy writer, this could be useful for people I know who are interested in the development of my work, namely family and friends. If I can't convince them I have skills in writing, I can at least educate them about what I do.

Jonathan McCalmont

I think it would be more inspiration than anything else. I've tried to write a couple of times but it's difficult as I come at it from the point of view of the critic (I start with subtext and come round to characters and plot last) but I'm sure it would be a good indicator of how complex and intelligent fantasy can be at its best.

Jacob Martin

It's hard for critics to write Fantasy because the critic tends to have more experience critiquing works of Fantasy rather than creating it. I'm sure you'll eventually find the right way to go about it, it took me years to figure out that I wanted to write satirical fantasy that wasn't parody but still had some serious things to say about modern life and how one can judge somebody as more human than somebody else.

Also, you have to have the right mindset to write certain types of Fantasy. I write about Changelings who exhibit human tendencies despite not being human, gained from the Human TV programs and Human media they encounter, which I write about as a young man with Asperger Syndrome. Asperger's sufferers were originally seen as potential Changelings way back when, so I identify with them. Plus nobody really has written much about Changelings, at least not from the point of view of an Asperger's person. At least I'm not writing Vampire porn, I predict that if I become successful, Changeling books will be where it's at in the next 20 years.

But you also have to have the willpower to write a Fantasy book. That's half the battle. I'm sure you could write lovely Fantasy books that make people think, despite your expressed dissatisfaction with the Fantasy genre you expressed in earlier blog posts. I guess good Fantasy relies as much on the motivation and wisdom of the Fantasy writer as their skills as a writer. The way I see it, a Magical society would treat Magic as science, much like Earth treats science as a path to technological advancement, rather than a deus ex machina.

Regards,
Jacob Martin

The comments to this entry are closed.